Latin America faces a decisive moment. In a new multipolar and more competitive global scenario, the countries of the region must re-evaluate their foreign policies, adapt to new power dynamics, and reconsider their strategic alliances—elements that will define their positioning in the coming decades. This article analyses the implications for Latin America with respect to China's growing influence, the historical relationship with the European Union and the United States, mapping out possible scenarios for the region's future.
China's Growing Influence: New Dynamics and Challenges
China has emerged as a key player in global geopolitics, and over the last two decades, its relations with Latin America have deepened through a strategy focused on strengthening trade ties, securing access to natural resources, and promoting infrastructure development. The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has been a fundamental pillar of this strategy, boosting investment in key sectors such as mining, energy, telecommunications, and transport. China has provided an expanding market for Latin American exports, especially in natural resources such as copper, soybeans, oil, and gas. Chinese investment has been particularly significant in countries such as Brazil, Argentina, Peru, and Chile, which have signed trade agreements and participated in large infrastructure projects, especially in the energy and mining sectors. In addition, cooperation in technology, education, and culture has been growing.
However, this relationship also presents risks. While commodity exports to China have been an important driver of several Latin American economies, particularly in the Southern Cone, dependence on these exports exposes the region to international price fluctuations. In addition, there has been increasing debate about the growing indebtedness of some Latin American countries to China, raising concerns over long-term economic sustainability, particularly with the rising dependence on Chinese loans and investments. Moreover, competition with the U.S. for influence in the region has intensified tensions, as China represents not only an economic alternative but also a geopolitical challenge to historic U.S. influence in Latin America. A recent case illustrating this challenge is the inauguration of the Chancay mega-port in Peru in the context of the Belt and Road Initiative, which will not only have economic and commercial repercussions for Peru and its neighbouring countries, but also geopolitical ones, marking a milestone in China's growing influence in the region.
The European Union: A Traditional Partner with Renewed Initiatives
The European Union (EU) is a traditional partner for Latin America. Bilateral relations have been based on political, trade, cultural, and democracy-promotion cooperation. In recent years, the EU has intensified its efforts to strengthen its ties with the region, highlighting the significance of trade agreements such as the one signed with Mercosur in 2019. This agreement, which is still in the process of ratification, seeks to promote trade and investment between the two regions.
However, the relationship with the EU faces challenges. Despite commercial advances, EU initiatives in Latin America have had limited impact compared to the strategic influence of China or the United States. The region needs the EU to be more proactive, going beyond trade agreements and engaging more deeply in joint cooperation to address structural problems affecting Latin American countries, such as poverty, inequality, and sustainability.
United States: Challenges and Opportunities of a Historic Relationship
The relationship between Latin America and the United States has been historically complex. Despite political and economic tensions, the U.S. remains a key partner in terms of trade, investment, and cooperation in areas such as security and counter-narcotics. However, in the last two decades, Latin America has been relegated in the U.S. international agenda, revealing that the U.S. continues to view the region primarily through a lens of national security and immigration, rather than economic development or political cooperation.
Despite this, Latin America must balance its relationship with the U.S. without falling into one-sided dependency in a multipolar world. While the U.S. faces internal challenges such as political polarisation and external challenges such as geopolitical competition with China, Latin America has the opportunity to diversify its international relations in a balanced way.
Looking Ahead: Towards a More Balanced Strategic Positioning of Latin America
Looking ahead, Latin America must pursue a strategy to diversify its political, economic, and trade relations in the face of its asymmetric relations with the great powers. The relationship with China will continue to grow, but the countries of the region must maximise the opportunities and mitigate the risks that could make them vulnerable. At the same time, relations with the European Union and the United States should be seen as an opportunity to foster cooperation in key areas such as innovation, sustainability, and education.
Through a multilateral approach, the region could seek to diversify its sources of investment and cooperation by strengthening its relations with these three actors through trade agreements, infrastructure investment, and sustainable development. Latin America has the potential to become a pivot between different powers, but the challenge lies in creating a common agenda that fosters greater regional coordination and promotes a vision of its own in the face of external interests. In this sense, initiatives such as CELAC, the Pacific Alliance, and Mercosur, although often criticised for their limitations, remain platforms that contribute to regional cooperation.
In this new geopolitical chessboard, the key for Latin America will be to strike a balance between global interests and its own development objectives. With an approach that promotes multilateral cooperation and regional integration, Latin America will be able to position itself as a relevant actor in an increasingly competitive world. The decisions taken by Latin American countries in the coming years will determine the region's place in this new geopolitical scenario.
The International Conference Latin America in a New Geopolitical Chessboard: Positioning and Projections Towards China, the European Union, and the United States will be broadcast live on Tuesday, December 3, 2024, from 9:00 AM to 1:10 PM (Buenos Aires local time) on UNTREF's YouTube channel at: https://www.youtube.com/live/zKmaojyT77M
References:
-
Aróstica, P. (2021) “China y Estados Unidos: un nuevo tablero para Latinoamérica”. En: Foreign Affairs Latinoamérica. Vol. 21, N°2. April/June. México. pp. 146-151.
-
Aróstica, P. & Sánchez, W. (Eds.). (2019) China y América Latina en una nueva fase: desafíos en el siglo XXI. Aróstica, P. (2019). "China y América Latina en el siglo XXI: asimetría y política exterior en la globalización económica". Santiago, Editorial Universitaria. pp. 85-101.
-
Barragán, M. & Sribman, A. (2024) “El ajedrez geopolítico de América Latina en el nuevo orden multipolar”. Revista CIDOB d’Afers Internacionals, n.º 136 (abril de 2024). pp. 11-33. En: https://www.cidob.org/publicaciones/el-ajedrez-geopolitico-de-america-l… (Accessed November 18, 2024).
-
Mijares, V. (2023) “Growing Sino–US Rivalry in Latin America: An Opportunity for the EU”. GIGA Focus Latin America. Number 5. En: https://www.giga-hamburg.de/en/publications/giga-focus/growing-sino-us-… (Accessed November 20, 2024).
-
Parlamento Europeo (2024). Fichas Temáticas sobre la Unión Europea, América Latina y el Caribe. En: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/factsheets/es/sheet/176/america-latina-y… (Accessed November 18, 2024).
(The opinions expressed in this blog are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the EU-LAC Foundation).